diff --git a/.planning/decisions/license.md b/.planning/decisions/license.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..b249189 --- /dev/null +++ b/.planning/decisions/license.md @@ -0,0 +1,69 @@ +# License decision — 2026-05-12 + +**Chose:** MIT License (already committed at `9b62db5`, confirmed here). + +## Rationale + +- **Project nature matches MIT's strengths.** Jarvis is a personal AI + assistant intended for single-user single-machine use. The author has + no commercial-licensing strategy, no patent portfolio to defend, and no + preference for copyleft. The license should be permissive and friction- + free — both for the author and for anyone curious enough to fork. +- **The interesting parts of the codebase are generic.** The agent loop, + the typed JSON Bus, the MCP runtime, the boundary-gate scripts, the + voice pipeline, and the R3F HUD scaffolding are all patterns other + Swift / macOS / agent-stack authors might want to lift. MIT removes + every barrier to that lift. +- **No contributor-agreement burden.** MIT does not require an explicit + CLA, contributor license grant, or DCO sign-off. For a solo project + that accepts the occasional drive-by PR via GitHub, MIT plus GitHub's + default inbound-equals-outbound rule (ToS §D.6) is enough. +- **Compatible with everything in the dependency graph.** All current + Swift Package Manager and pnpm dependencies are MIT, Apache-2.0, or + BSD — no GPL/AGPL surfaces to consider. MIT downstream of Apache-2.0 + is a recognized clean combination. +- **Apple Silicon / ML model weights are separate.** The Orpheus, Qwen, + and `nomic-embed-text` weights are not in this repo; their licenses + govern themselves and are not affected by the host repo's license. + This is consistent with how the wider open-source ML stack treats + weights-as-data. + +## Considered and rejected + +- **Apache 2.0** — equivalent permissiveness, plus an explicit patent + grant and a `NOTICE` mechanism. The patent-grant story is meaningful + for larger projects with corporate contributors, but adds boilerplate + noise (per-file headers, NOTICE handling) for negligible benefit on a + solo personal project. **If a corporate contributor ever proposes a + meaningful patch, revisit this decision.** +- **MPL-2.0** — file-level copyleft. Useful for projects that want to + let proprietary integrators ship without re-licensing the whole + product. The author has no such integration plans; the complexity + isn't earning its keep. +- **AGPL-3.0** — copyleft including network use. Designed to force + SaaS forks to share. Jarvis is single-user single-machine — there is + no SaaS surface to protect. AGPL also signals "we don't want + corporate adopters," which is the opposite of the message the public + repo is sending. + +## Implementation + +- `LICENSE` at repo root (MIT, committed at `9b62db5`). +- **No per-file license headers.** MIT does not require them. The repo + is large and adding 200+ identical headers would noise the diff for + zero legal benefit. The repo-root `LICENSE` file plus the project name + in the copyright line satisfies attribution. +- `README.md` "License" section points to `LICENSE` and names the + license explicitly (this commit updates the section, which previously + contradicted the actual MIT grant). +- `CONTRIBUTING.md` and `SECURITY.md` reference the license by name. +- The copyright line reads `Copyright (c) 2026 James Maes / KofTwentyTwo`. + When 2027 ships, update to `2026-2027` rather than just incrementing. + +## Revisit triggers + +Open this decision back up if: +- A corporate contributor proposes a meaningful patch (consider Apache 2.0). +- The project gains a SaaS deployment surface (consider AGPL). +- A dependency adopts a license that is incompatible with MIT (re-examine + the whole stack — but unlikely given the current dependency set).