Compare commits

..
Author SHA1 Message Date
james.maesandCodex 73689ecc6e fix(ci): provide a stable verification gate across branches
Co-Authored-By: Codex <noreply@openai.com>
2026-10-21 03:10:08 -05:00
james.maesandCodex 05a2a5217a fix: audit rc worker pins independently of native workers (#58)
Co-authored-by: Codex <noreply@openai.com>
2026-10-21 02:23:51 -05:00
james.maesandCodex 7d73ac90b6 fix: distinguish missing RC refs from GitHub error bodies (#57)
* fix: distinguish missing rc refs from github error bodies

Co-Authored-By: Codex <noreply@openai.com>

* fix: reject empty ref responses across jq versions

Co-Authored-By: Codex <noreply@openai.com>

---------

Co-authored-by: Codex <noreply@openai.com>
2026-10-21 02:15:32 -05:00
12 changed files with 121 additions and 28 deletions

No files matched your search

+5 -5
View File
@@ -135,7 +135,7 @@ jobs:
echo "merge_sha=$merge_sha"
echo "merged_at=$merged_at"
} >> "$GITHUB_OUTPUT"
echo "Pushed $branch; CircleCI publish_release_candidate cuts the RC." >> "$GITHUB_STEP_SUMMARY"
echo "Pushed $branch; the CircleCI publisher cuts the RC." >> "$GITHUB_STEP_SUMMARY"
echo "Release line: $branch. Waiting without a runner for qbit-rc-published." >> "$GITHUB_STEP_SUMMARY"
- name: Persist trusted release intent
if: steps.merge.outputs.merge_sha != ''
@@ -203,7 +203,7 @@ jobs:
raise ReleaseFailure("Status response does not identify the exact release merge")
# Circle's workflow Check Run is stable even when job statuses receive -1/-2 suffixes.
publishers = [x for x in status.get("check_runs", [])
if x.get("name") == "publish_release_candidate" and x.get("app", {}).get("id") == 18001]
if x.get("name") in ("publish_release_candidate", "verify") and x.get("app", {}).get("id") == 18001]
if not publishers:
return ""
publisher = max(publishers, key=lambda x: x["id"])
@@ -265,10 +265,10 @@ jobs:
job.get('branch'), str(job.get('build_num'))) != (repo, merge, branch, build):
raise ReleaseFailure('Timeout job does not identify the exact cut')
workflow = job.get('workflows', {})
if workflow.get('workflow_name') != 'publish_release_candidate' or workflow.get('job_name') != 'qqq-orb/mvn_publish':
if workflow.get('workflow_name') not in ('publish_release_candidate', 'verify') or workflow.get('job_name') != 'qqq-orb/mvn_publish':
raise ReleaseFailure('Unexpected Circle publication workflow/job')
if (publisher.get('head_sha') != merge or publisher.get('app', {}).get('id') != 18001
or publisher.get('name') != 'publish_release_candidate'
or publisher.get('name') != workflow.get('workflow_name')
or publisher.get('status') != 'completed' or publisher.get('conclusion') != 'failure'):
raise ReleaseFailure('Recovery requires the failed exact Circle publisher')
from urllib.parse import urlsplit
@@ -335,7 +335,7 @@ jobs:
directory = pathlib.Path(directory)
status = json.loads((directory / 'status.json').read_text())
intent = json.loads((directory / 'intent.json').read_text())
publishers = [p for p in status['check_runs'] if p.get('name') == 'publish_release_candidate' and p.get('app', {}).get('id') == 18001]
publishers = [p for p in status['check_runs'] if p.get('name') in ('publish_release_candidate', 'verify') and p.get('app', {}).get('id') == 18001]
if status.get('sha') != merge or not publishers:
raise ReleaseFailure('Exact publisher evidence missing')
class NoRedirect(urllib.request.HTTPRedirectHandler):
+18 -6
View File
@@ -61,11 +61,23 @@ parser is pinned to PyYAML 6.0.3 and uses its safe loader.
| Event | Workflow | Job contract |
| --- | --- | --- |
| develop | publish_snapshot | existing mvn_publish, snapshot |
| release/* | publish_release_candidate | existing mvn_publish, release_candidate |
| vX.Y.Z tag resolving to the checkout | publish_release | existing mvn_publish, release |
| main, feature/*, hotfix/*, other/unknown branch | test_only | existing mvn_test_only |
| Disabled publication or unrecognized/unproven tag | test_only | full verification, no publication |
| develop | verify | existing mvn_publish, snapshot |
| release/* | verify | existing mvn_publish, release_candidate |
| vX.Y.Z tag resolving to the checkout | verify | existing mvn_publish, release |
| main, feature/*, hotfix/*, other/unknown branch | verify | existing mvn_test_only |
| Disabled publication or unrecognized/unproven tag | verify | full verification, no publication |
Generated `qbit`, `core`, `frontend-core`, and `frontend-material` pipelines use
the stable workflow name `verify`. All selected jobs, dependencies and filters
remain intact; this adds no executor or duplicate build. Other profiles retain
their existing workflow names and native checks.
When upgrading from legacy workflow names, upgrade the immutable RC worker pin
alongside the orb so finalization recognizes both names. Confirm the CircleCI
app's successful `verify` check on the exact migration commit before replacing
legacy required contexts. Require `setup` and `verify` on managed branches,
preserving other required checks and controls. Human approval is not required;
automated checks authorize the migration.
The pipeline SHA must match the checkout when Circle supplies it. A tagged release
must resolve to that checkout; missing local tags are fetched individually. A main
@@ -182,7 +194,7 @@ manifest validation already ran in setup. It adds no new security scanner and
makes no security-scanning claim. Keep docs-only disabled if those paths are build
inputs or packaged application content.
The light route keeps workflow `test_only` and names its job
The light route keeps workflow `verify` and names its job
`qqq-orb/mvn_test_only`. Verify actual CircleCI/GitHub status contexts on the canary
before changing any protection rule; workflow/job identity alone is not proof of
the hosted context name. Current protections must not be removed speculatively.
+12 -1
View File
@@ -26,7 +26,8 @@ https://docs.github.com/en/actions/reference/workflows-and-actions/events-that-t
- Finalization retrieves the unique unexpired intent artifact and verifies its
originating successful `release-rc.yml` run, repository, trigger and attempt.
Callback fields must match that immutable intent.
- The exact merge SHA must have a successful `publish_release_candidate` Check Run
- The exact merge SHA must have a successful `verify` (or legacy
`publish_release_candidate`) Check Run
from CircleCI app ID `18001`; unrelated job statuses cannot authorize release.
Terminal publisher failure stops finalization immediately. Pending/absent publication cannot authorize a tag.
The RC bump must have exactly that one parent and the release branch must still
@@ -107,3 +108,13 @@ is gone, the completed release needs no recovery dispatch. Ordinary callbacks an
scheduled reconciliation retain the requirement for a successful Circle publisher.
Central status API: https://central.sonatype.org/publish/publish-portal-api/
### Auditing independent worker revisions
The estate audit accepts `rc_worker_sha` in a profile or repository policy. For
example, set `profiles.qbit.rc_worker_sha` to the approved immutable RC worker
commit and keep `--worker-sha` at the approved revision for unchanged native
workers. The audit still compares every caller to its exact canonical template
and rejects mutable or mismatched pins. This avoids a fleet-wide native caller
update when only RC release behavior changes. Required-check policy is separate;
omitting it continues to report enforcement as unknown.
+6
View File
@@ -441,6 +441,12 @@ def main():
if expected and (not re.fullmatch(r"[0-9a-fA-F]{40}", expected) or git("rev-parse", "HEAD") != (expected + "\n").encode()):
raise ManifestError("Checkout does not match the pipeline commit")
output = PROFILE_TEMPLATES[config["profile"]](config, os.environ.get("CIRCLE_BRANCH", ""), os.environ.get("CIRCLE_TAG", ""))
if config["profile"] in ("qbit", "core", "frontend-core", "frontend-material"):
# One whole-workflow check follows the same commit from feature to release.
# Keep every selected job, dependency and filter; add no runner or duplicate build.
if len(output["workflows"]) != 1:
raise ManifestError("Stable verification requires exactly one selected workflow")
output["workflows"] = {"verify": next(iter(output["workflows"].values()))}
parameters = continuation_parameters(config["profile"])
if config["profile"] == "core":
output["parameters"] = copy.deepcopy(CORE_TEMPLATE["parameters"])
+6
View File
@@ -441,6 +441,12 @@ def main():
if expected and (not re.fullmatch(r"[0-9a-fA-F]{40}", expected) or git("rev-parse", "HEAD") != (expected + "\n").encode()):
raise ManifestError("Checkout does not match the pipeline commit")
output = PROFILE_TEMPLATES[config["profile"]](config, os.environ.get("CIRCLE_BRANCH", ""), os.environ.get("CIRCLE_TAG", ""))
if config["profile"] in ("qbit", "core", "frontend-core", "frontend-material"):
# One whole-workflow check follows the same commit from feature to release.
# Keep every selected job, dependency and filter; add no runner or duplicate build.
if len(output["workflows"]) != 1:
raise ManifestError("Stable verification requires exactly one selected workflow")
output["workflows"] = {"verify": next(iter(output["workflows"].values()))}
parameters = continuation_parameters(config["profile"])
if config["profile"] == "core":
output["parameters"] = copy.deepcopy(CORE_TEMPLATE["parameters"])
+1 -1
View File
@@ -116,7 +116,7 @@ def reconcile(api, repo):
validate_run(run, intent, repo, merge, run_id)
checks = api.request(prefix + 'commits/' + merge + '/check-runs?filter=latest&per_page=100')
publishers = [c for c in checks.get('check_runs', [])
if c.get('name') == 'publish_release_candidate' and c.get('app', {}).get('id') == 18001]
if c.get('name') in ('publish_release_candidate', 'verify') and c.get('app', {}).get('id') == 18001]
if not publishers:
return 'publisher-running'
publisher = max(publishers, key=lambda c: c['id'])
+19
View File
@@ -74,6 +74,25 @@ class AuditTests(unittest.TestCase):
report = audit.audit(entry, Snapshot({'.qqq-ci.yml': audit.generator.yaml.safe_dump(manifest)}), VERSION, SHA, POLICY)
self.assertIn('missing_rc_bridge', [f['code'] for f in report['findings']])
def test_rc_pin_policy_does_not_force_unchanged_auxiliary_worker_updates(self):
entry = dict(ENTRY, name='qbit-authentik', nameWithOwner='QRun-IO/qbit-authentik')
rc_sha = 'b' * 40
definition = audit.auxiliary.BRIDGES['qbit-schema-drift']
manifest = {'profile': 'qbit', 'orb_version': VERSION, 'default_branch': 'develop', 'release_completion': True}
files = {audit.rc_worker.CALLER_PATH: audit.rc_worker.generate(rc_sha),
definition['path']: audit.generator.yaml.safe_dump(audit.auxiliary.canonical('qbit-schema-drift', SHA), sort_keys=False),
'.qqq-ci.yml': audit.generator.yaml.safe_dump(manifest),
'.circleci/config.yml': audit.generator.yaml.safe_dump(audit.standard.canonical_caller('qbit', VERSION))}
policy = dict(POLICY, rc_worker_sha=rc_sha)
self.assertEqual('pass', audit.audit(entry, Snapshot(files), VERSION, SHA, policy)['status'])
for pin in (SHA, 'main', ''):
with self.subTest(pin=pin):
report = audit.audit(entry, Snapshot(files), VERSION, SHA, dict(POLICY, rc_worker_sha=pin))
self.assertTrue(report['findings'])
files[definition['path']] = files[definition['path']].replace(SHA, rc_sha)
report = audit.audit(entry, Snapshot(files), VERSION, SHA, policy)
self.assertIn('native_maintenance_bridge_drift', [f['code'] for f in report['findings']])
def test_qbit_rc_bridge_missing_drift_pin_and_duplicate(self):
entry = dict(ENTRY, name='qbit-test', nameWithOwner='QRun-IO/qbit-test')
path = audit.rc_worker.CALLER_PATH
+18 -13
View File
@@ -192,10 +192,12 @@ class PipelineTests(unittest.TestCase):
return result
def assert_full(self, result, workflow="test_only"):
self.assertEqual(list(result["workflows"]), [workflow])
self.assertEqual(list(result["workflows"]), ["verify"])
self.assertNotIn("docs_only", result.get("jobs", {}))
job, options = next(iter(result["workflows"][workflow]["jobs"][0].items()))
job, options = next(iter(result["workflows"]["verify"]["jobs"][0].items()))
self.assertEqual(job, "qqq-orb/mvn_test_only" if workflow == "test_only" else "qqq-orb/mvn_publish")
if workflow != "test_only":
self.assertEqual(options["branch_type"], workflow.removeprefix("publish_"))
self.assertEqual(options["context"], ["qqq-maven-registry-credentials"])
self.assertFalse(options["compile_before_verify"])
return options
@@ -298,8 +300,8 @@ class PipelineTests(unittest.TestCase):
self.change_docs()
for packed in ([False, True] if PACKED else [False]):
result = self.render(packed=packed)
self.assertEqual(list(result["workflows"]), ["test_only"])
options = result["workflows"]["test_only"]["jobs"][0]["docs_only"]
self.assertEqual(list(result["workflows"]), ["verify"])
options = result["workflows"]["verify"]["jobs"][0]["docs_only"]
self.assertEqual(options["name"], "qqq-orb/mvn_test_only")
self.assertIn("git diff --check", result["jobs"]["docs_only"]["steps"][1]["run"]["command"])
(self.repo / "App.java").write_text("changed\n", encoding="utf-8")
@@ -360,8 +362,8 @@ class PipelineTests(unittest.TestCase):
for branch, tag, workflow in events:
with self.subTest(workflow=workflow):
result = self.render(CIRCLE_BRANCH=branch, CIRCLE_TAG=tag)
self.assertEqual(list(result["workflows"]), [workflow])
actual = result["workflows"][workflow]["jobs"]
self.assertEqual(list(result["workflows"]), ["verify"])
actual = result["workflows"]["verify"]["jobs"]
expected = baseline["workflows"][workflow]["jobs"]
self.assertEqual(len(actual), len(expected))
for before, after in zip(expected, actual):
@@ -422,8 +424,8 @@ class PipelineTests(unittest.TestCase):
with self.subTest(branch=branch, enabled=enabled):
result = self.render(CIRCLE_BRANCH=branch, QQQ_CI_RUN_PLAYWRIGHT=str(enabled).lower())
workflow = base + ("_with_playwright" if enabled else "")
self.assertEqual(list(result["workflows"]), [workflow])
jobs = result["workflows"][workflow]["jobs"]
self.assertEqual(list(result["workflows"]), ["verify"])
jobs = result["workflows"]["verify"]["jobs"]
self.assertEqual(len(jobs), 2 if enabled else 1)
maven = [j for j in jobs if next(iter(j)).startswith("qqq-orb/mvn_frontend_")]
self.assertEqual(len(maven), 1)
@@ -454,8 +456,10 @@ class PipelineTests(unittest.TestCase):
("hotfix/fix", "", "publish_hotfix_release"), ("", "publish-fixture", "publish_feature"),
("", "v1.0.0", "publish_release")]:
result = self.render(CIRCLE_BRANCH=branch, CIRCLE_TAG=tag)
self.assertEqual(list(result["workflows"]), [workflow])
options = next(iter(result["workflows"][workflow]["jobs"][0].values()))
self.assertEqual(list(result["workflows"]), ["verify"])
options = next(iter(result["workflows"]["verify"]["jobs"][0].values()))
expected_kind = {"publish_hotfix_release": "hotfix"}.get(workflow, workflow.removeprefix("publish_"))
self.assertEqual(options["branch_type"], expected_kind)
if profile == "frontend-core":
self.assertTrue(options["npm_trusted_publishing"])
self.assertEqual(options["node_version"], "24.21")
@@ -463,9 +467,9 @@ class PipelineTests(unittest.TestCase):
else:
self.assertEqual(options["context"], ["qqq-maven-registry-credentials"])
main = self.render(CIRCLE_BRANCH="main")
self.assertEqual(list(main["workflows"]), ["publish_release" if profile == "frontend-core" else "test_only"])
self.assertEqual(list(main["workflows"]), ["verify"])
rc_tag = self.render(CIRCLE_BRANCH="", CIRCLE_TAG="v1.0.0-RC.1")
self.assertEqual(list(rc_tag["workflows"]), ["publish_release" if profile == "frontend-core" else "test_only"])
self.assertEqual(list(rc_tag["workflows"]), ["verify"])
def test_profile_specific_options_rejected(self):
for profile, options in [("qbit", {"node_version": "22"}), ("frontend-core", {"browsers": False}),
@@ -532,7 +536,8 @@ class PipelineTests(unittest.TestCase):
{"CIRCLE_BRANCH": "integration-example"}):
result = self.render(**environment)
if environment.get("CIRCLE_BRANCH") != "integration-example":
self.assertIn("publish_release", result["workflows"])
self.assertEqual(list(result["workflows"]), ["verify"])
self.assertEqual(result["workflows"]["verify"]["jobs"][0]["qqq-orb/mvn_publish"]["branch_type"], "release")
if PACKED:
self.assertEqual(result, self.render(packed=True, **environment))
+11
View File
@@ -58,6 +58,17 @@ class FixtureAPI:
class SweepTests(unittest.TestCase):
def test_stable_gate_and_mixed_name_latest_failure(self):
api = FixtureAPI()
api.status['check_runs'][0]['name'] = 'verify'
self.assertEqual('dispatched', sweep.reconcile(api, REPO))
api.sent.clear()
api.status['check_runs'].append(dict(api.status['check_runs'][0],
id=10, name='publish_release_candidate', conclusion='failure'))
with self.assertRaises(sweep.InvalidIntent):
sweep.reconcile(api, REPO)
self.assertEqual([], api.sent)
def test_idle_never_dispatches_or_reads_artifacts(self):
api = FixtureAPI(); api.lock = None
self.assertEqual('idle', sweep.reconcile(api, REPO))
+11
View File
@@ -23,6 +23,17 @@ def bump(parent=SHA, version='1.2.3-RC.4'):
class ReleaseGuardTests(unittest.TestCase):
def test_stable_workflow_preserves_exact_source_and_latest_attempt_checks(self):
result = status()
result['check_runs'][0]['name'] = 'verify'
self.assertEqual('1.2.3-RC.4', evaluate(SHA, result, bump()))
result['check_runs'].append(dict(result['check_runs'][0], id=10, conclusion='failure'))
with self.assertRaisesRegex(Failure, 'CircleCI failed'):
evaluate(SHA, result, bump())
result['check_runs'] = [dict(result['check_runs'][0], head_sha=OTHER)]
with self.assertRaises(Failure):
evaluate(SHA, result, bump())
def test_success_exact_built_source(self):
self.assertEqual('1.2.3-RC.4', evaluate(SHA, status(), bump()))
+9
View File
@@ -30,6 +30,15 @@ def validate(job, publisher):
class TimeoutRecoveryTests(unittest.TestCase):
def test_stable_gate_must_match_the_actual_publishing_workflow(self):
job, publisher = evidence()
job['workflows']['workflow_name'] = 'verify'
publisher['name'] = 'verify'
validate(job, publisher)
publisher['name'] = 'publish_release_candidate'
with self.assertRaises(Failure):
validate(job, publisher)
def test_exact_upload_timeout_after_successful_verify(self):
self.assertEqual((124, 0), validate(*evidence()))
+5 -2
View File
@@ -6,6 +6,8 @@ Example: python tools/audit_estate.py --inventory inventory.json --orb-version 0
Policy: {"profiles":{"qbit":{"required_checks":{"main":["observed context"],
"develop":["observed context"]}}},"repositories":{"QRun-IO/example":{...}}}.
Only use contexts verified on hosted canaries. Absent policy is unknown, not pass.
A profile/repository policy may set rc_worker_sha independently of --worker-sha
so an RC-only worker change does not require updating unchanged native workers.
"""
import argparse
import base64
@@ -209,11 +211,12 @@ def audit(entry, snapshot, version, worker_sha, policy):
if profile == 'qbit' and (rc_enabled or existing_rc):
path = rc_worker.CALLER_PATH
raw = rc_source
rc_sha = policy.get("rc_worker_sha", worker_sha)
if raw is None:
finding('missing_rc_bridge', path)
elif not re.fullmatch(r'[0-9a-f]{40}', worker_sha or ''):
elif not re.fullmatch(r'[0-9a-f]{40}', rc_sha or ''):
finding('native_pin_policy_missing', path)
elif raw != rc_worker.generate(worker_sha):
elif raw != rc_worker.generate(rc_sha):
finding('rc_bridge_drift', path)
else:
native_paths.add(path)